Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hugh Thomas's avatar

When you write: "life is the absolute and death is subjected to life, or life is the absolute and life is subjected to death," I think the second "life is the absolute" is supposed to be "death is the absolute."

I ran across yesterday, in an essay by David Lodge of all people, the following quotation about Bakhtin: "A fascinating report of a debate in which he participated in 1918 says of Bakhtin, 'At some points he did recognize, and even expressed appreciation of socialism, but he complained of, and worried about, the fact that socialism had no care for the dead.'" I guess I found this striking because it seems clear that "care for the dead" is something Communism is not equipped to provide.

On the other hand, Benjamin's theses on the philosophy of history also come to mind. ("Not even the dead will be safe...")

Expand full comment
Lenny Smith's avatar

Dear Beatrice: What a lovely name! I love that you are addressing to topic of death, one that we all try not to think about at all! One conviction I now have, at 82, is that we are not here as human beings, perhaps on a mission to mature, grow, develop and evolve into a high level of knowledge and spirituality. Rather, we are here as eternal spirits, lovely, kind, gentle, extremely intelligent and knowledgeable, on assignment to be earthlings, humans, eventually with much ego, if at all. As eternal spirits, WE DO NOT DIE, although we will drop these earth suits when they have served us well. How else could we ever smell the flowers and see the lovely evenings and touch our loved ones?

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts